Why Skills-Based Testing Wins with Candidates and Hiring Managers

 

Last summer, I encouraged my son – a college student and passionate cross-country runner – to apply for a job at a major retailer specializing in running gear. He knows running shoes inside and out and would have been a perfect fit: knowledgeable, enthusiastic, and great with people.

He never even got an interview.

Why? Because he was honest about not having retail experience. The automated screening system tossed his application before he had a chance to show what he could actually do.

He’s not alone.

REAL TALENT IS BEING OVERLOOKED

Every year, thousands of capable candidates are screened out, not because they lack ability, but because the hiring process never gave them a chance to show it.

This is exactly what skills-based testing is designed to solve. Instead of relying on résumé screeners or personality questions, skills-based testing lets job seekers show you what they can actually do.

Skills-based assessments, like job simulations and work samples, place candidates in realistic workplace situations and give them an opportunity to prove their job-related skills.

This idea isn’t new. I’ve spent over 30 years developing skills-based job simulations for hiring. But despite the clear advantages, many companies still overlook this proven strategy – relying instead on outdated screening tools that fail to reliably predict job performance or success.

CANDIDATES WANT TO PROVE THEMSELVES

Here’s the secret many hiring teams miss:  candidates aren’t afraid of being tested – they welcome the opportunity to demonstrate their skills.

Compared to endless online forms or abstract questionnaires, a skills-based assessment is a breath of fresh air.

1. It Feels Fair

When you’re evaluated based on your ability to do the actual work, the rules are clear. There’s no guessing game, no secret formula, just a transparent chance to perform the job.

Candidates walk away feeling like they were given a real shot, even if they don’t land the job. That sense of fairness builds trust in your brand.

2. It’s Relevant and Makes Sense

Let’s face it – with many screening tools, there’s no clear connection between the questions being asked and the requirement of the job. But an assessment that mirrors actual job tasks? That clicks.

A customer service candidate understands why they’re handling a difficult call. A coder gets why they’re being asked to fix a bug. The assessment aligns with the role, making the experience logical, objective, and engaging.

3. It Reduces Stress

Candidates typically are more at ease performing real tasks than responding to vague or abstract questions. In a simulation, it’s not about memorizing answers or trying to guess what the employer is looking for – it’s about doing what they know.

Skills-based testing offers a familiar environment, and that helps candidates perform at their best.

4. It Levels the Playing Field

There’s something deeply validating about being given the chance to prove yourself, especially if your résumé doesn’t tell the whole story. This is especially true for career changers, students, veterans, or those reentering the workforce. They may not check every box in terms of prior job titles, but they often have the skills. A skills-based simulation allows them to prove it. For someone like my son, that would have been the difference between an automatic screen-out and a summer job he would have loved.

SKILLS-BASED TESTING CREATES A BETTER CANDIDATE EXPERIENCE

Here’s another point hiring teams often overlook: job candidates remember how your hiring process made them feel. If the experience is relevant, fair, and allows them to showcase their skills, they’re more likely to:

  • Stay in the process
  • Recommend your company to others
  • Accept your offer if one is made

GIVES TALENT A CHANCE TO SHINE

Perhaps the most compelling reason to adopt skills-based hiring? It shows you who a person really is. Résumés can be padded. Interviews can be rehearsed. But actual job tasks? That’s real.

There’s no faking your way through a live technical issue, a sales pitch, or recommending the right running shoes. It’s just you, the task, and the opportunity to shine.

That’s why candidates prefer skills-based assessments.

  • They’re fair.
  • They’re relevant.
  • They’re objective.

If you want to hire better, give candidates the opportunity to show you what they can do. That’s what they want. And it’s what your business needs.

 

RELATED TOPICS

5 TIPS TO OPTIMIZE THE APPLICANT JOURNEY

HIRING FOR JOB SKILLS: THE REAL DRIVER OF BUSINESS GROWTH

PRE-HIRE TESTING IS BROKEN – HERE’S WHAT ACTUALLY WORKS

 

 Joe LaTorre is the Director of Innovation at Employment Technologies, where he leads the design and development of immersive assessment solutions that enrich candidate experiences and drive measurable client results. With 30+ years of global consulting expertise, Joe has designed award-winning job simulations used by clients across North America, Asia, and Europe – helping organizations hire top talent with confidence.